It may seem odd to start a science section with an opinion page, but it’s important to understand that while there is generally only one scientific truth, how we arrive at that truth is often a circuitous path. Often, in ongoing study of a subject with science, we ferret out the mistakes and the misconceptions that inevitably occur in the early phases as hypotheses are explored, theories expanded, and new possibilities discovered. This is the nature of science. It works very well, but certainly requires time for accurate analysis. Most importantly, it often requires persistence and follow-up to find the real truth.
I am a scientist, a retired medical doctor with 35 years of practice experience in science, and have read an untold number of scientific studies over the years, mostly about the human condition. I also have an undergraduate degree (Bachelor of Science in Biology) which included some studies in Marine Invertebrate Zoology at the Gulf Coast Research Lab in Ocean Springs, Mississippi. While I don’t consider myself expert in all the science of Puget Sound beaches, it does give me a solid basis for the analysis of existing science. As I begin to read and dissect papers that are purported to reach certain conclusions, I am disturbed by the misuse of some of these studies by industry. It will be my goal to share my critiques as I try to gain broader understanding about just what the science does and does not say about commercial aquaculture techniques.
If my critiques pique your interest, I would encourage you to obtain and read the entire scientific study, as abstracts are by their very nature limited.
These are my opinions about the articles and I’ve asked for no endorsement by the board of PHI. It is not my intention to have a blog page at this time, but you may reach me with comments through the contact page.
Ron Smith MD